Skip to main content

An expert group of engineers, including Cornell Engineering Dean Lance Collins and Professor Tom O'Rourke, tour the Canarsie Tunnel. A benchwall lines the tunnel on the right.


While speaking at an event in early December, Lance Collins, the Joseph Silbert Dean of Engineering, noticed his phone receiving an unusual number of messages. He continued his speech, not knowing until later that he was being contacted on behalf of New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo for a special project.

The governor wanted to ask Collins some questions regarding New York City’s Canarsie Tunnel, a vital underwater subway path connecting Manhattan to Brooklyn. Flooding from Superstorm Sandy in 2012 had badly damaged the century-old tunnel, which was set to close for 15 months of repairs beginning in April. The shutdown of the tunnel’s L train service was so dreaded by commuters in New York that some had dubbed it “L-pocalypse.”

Professor Tom O'Rourke, left, speaks with N.Y. Gov. Andrew Cuomo during a tour of the Canarsie Tunnel on Dec. 14.

But thanks to Ivy League ingenuity – and engineering – there’s a good chance “L-pocalypse” won’t befall the Big Apple. What began with a few questions resulted in an entirely new plan to avert the shutdown, and perhaps a new model for how major infrastructure projects can be evaluated.

Assessing the problem

Collins and Cuomo were joined on a conference call by a number of officials and engineers, including Tom O’Rourke, the Thomas R. Briggs professor of civil and environment engineering with expertise in underground infrastructure and transportation systems.

“Cuomo said he wanted a fresh set of eyes to look at the tunnel plan. He wanted us to see if we thought it was the best way forward or if we had any alternative ideas that might help keep the tunnel operational,” said Collins.


The group discussed the work that needed to be done to the tunnel, parts of which were beginning to erode from the salt water that had flooded it six years earlier. Its concrete benchwall – a 2-foot-wide walkway stretching the length of the tunnel – was deteriorating in some areas, endangering the track and exposing the power and signal cables encased within.

Soon after the call, Collins and O’Rourke received a detailed analysis of the tunnel and its proposed rehabilitation plan. After an in-depth review of the report, they were asked to join a midnight tour of the tunnel with Cuomo and engineering professors from Columbia University, including Mary Boyce, the dean of the Fu Foundation School of Engineering and Applied Science.

With flashlights, hardhats and other protective gear, the team descended into the tunnel during the early morning hours of Dec. 14. They observed that while some areas of the benchwall remained intact, others had begun to crumble. In other areas, the benchwall had acted as a sponge, absorbing salt water that, in turn, was corroding the cables inside.

Collins described the tour as informative and an exhilarating experience for the engineering team. He added that Cuomo was equally engaged.

“I was amazed by the command the governor had of the details regarding the tunnel,” said Collins. “If you think about everything it takes to run a state government, you wouldn’t think he could have this level of understanding. It was impressive.”

The team emerged later that night, galvanized and ready to dig deeper.

In 2012, Hurricane Sandy filled the Canarsie Tunnel with salt water, from the Avenue D Fan Plant to the North 7th Street Fan Plant.

Proposing a new solution

The Cornell and Columbia engineers began examining different rehabilitation options. They worked collaboratively through winter break, mostly in New York City so they could exchange ideas and begin to piece together an alternative proposal to the existing rehabilitation plan. They toured the Hudson River Tunnel, consulted extensively with officials from the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) and Amtrak, peppered consultants with questions, and studied state-of-the-art rail tunnels in other big cities, including Hong Kong, London and Riyadh.

The end result: a proposal to renovate the Canarsie Tunnel while keeping it operational, safe, on time and on budget. Night and weekend closures would be required, but only one of the tunnel’s two tracks would close at a time, allowing for continuous service.

“This is really a unique design, a unique system,” Cuomo said as he announced the new proposal during a Jan. 3 press conference. “It’s faster, it’s cheaper, it’s better than the way we’ve been doing it now.”

“Technology is typically advanced through the integration of existing innovations as opposed to the invention of something completely new from whole cloth.”

Lance Collins, the Joseph Silbert Dean of Engineering at Cornell

Instead of replacing miles of cables inside the benchwall, as the original plan had proposed, a racking system would suspend new cables on the side of the tunnel. This would allow the existing cables to continue powering the train while new cables are installed and jacketed in fireproof material. And instead of laboriously replacing 32,000 feet of benchwall, the plan proposes the wall remain where structurally stable and be fortified with fiber-reinforced polymer wrap where needed.

The racking system has been used in the construction of modern subway tunnels and the fireproof material is used in the airline industry, but neither has been applied to a rehabilitation project of this kind, according to Collins, who said the fiber-reinforced polymer wrap is also a proven technology borrowed from other infrastructure projects.

“It’s used today to hold together pillars of bridges that were damaged in earthquakes,” Collins said. “That is a far more structurally challenging environment than a benchwall. We’re simply using it for a very different application.”

To monitor the Canarsie Tunnel’s interior, “smart” fiber-optic sensor cables would run along the remaining benchwall to detect small shifts or cracks. Like the other technologies, it has proven effective in projects outside of the U.S., and has even been tested in O’Rourke’s Cornell laboratory.

O’Rourke said data gained from the fiber-optic cables would allow engineers to learn more about the Canarsie Tunnel’s condition than previously possible.

“The fiber optics and other proposed sensors allow us to create a ‘smart’ tunnel that can detect very small levels of deformation and changes in structural integrity before there is serious loss of capacity in the system,” said O’Rourke, who added the plan also calls for a complementary high-resolution LiDAR system – a laser detection technology – to periodically map the surface of the tunnel and monitor it for deterioration.

An opportunity to lead the country

Collins said he is genuinely impressed with the original rehabilitation plan and emphasized that the new proposal could not have been conceived without the comprehensive work that had already been done. But he added that letting a group of outside experts re-examine the plan and “kick the tires” was an excellent idea that could be replicated in the future.

“I see this as a case study of how major infrastructure projects could be done,” said Collins, who noted that academia is a good place to find experts with knowledge of emerging technology and outside-the-box thinking.

An expert panel, including Columbia Engineering Dean Mary Boyce, left, and Cornell Engineering Dean Lance Collins, presents recommendations Jan. 3 for the Canarsie Tunnel rehabilitation project.

“Technology is typically advanced through the integration of existing innovations as opposed to the invention of something completely new from whole cloth,” said Collins, “and that’s what we were able to do, come up with a creative solution that weaves proven technologies into an integrated system.”

O’Rourke pointed out that rehabilitating the tunnel with smart sensor technology provides an enormous opportunity for New York agencies and engineering firms to partner with universities and assume a leadership role in developing intelligent infrastructure.

“This shifts the paradigm from current practice to construction empowered by distributed sensors and artificial intelligence,” O’Rourke said. “It can be an important step forward as the nation faces the challenge of addressing its aging infrastructure and bringing service and resources more effectively to the people, not only in New York, but across the United States.”

City officials hope renovations can begin sometime around April, as originally planned, but this time with the L train remaining in service.

Syl Kacapyr is public relations and content manager for the College of Engineering.

Watch highlights from the governor's Jan. 3 press conference.




探探直播 JAV名优馆app 小酒窝直播app 花心视频app 麻豆传媒 心上人直播 麻豆传媒直播app 比心app 小仙女 探探直播app 月亮视频app 初见直播app 花样视频app 桃花直播app 樱花视频 香蕉视频app AVBOBO 橘子直播 水晶直播 十里桃花直播app JAV名优馆app 台湾swag 小狐仙直播app 铁牛 快喵 小狐仙直播app 小猪视频 swag台湾app 污直播 夜狼直播 和欢视频app 小怪兽app 媚妹秀 色秀直播 暖暖直播 火爆社区 黄鱼视频app 7秒鱼app AVBOBO 享爱app 火爆社区app 花秀神器app 杏吧直播app Avbobo 快喵app 猛虎直播 仙人掌 小猪视频app 蜜柚app 压寨直播app 泡芙视频 丝瓜视频app 柠檬视频 尤蜜视频 年轻人片app 性直播 九尾狐直播 黄瓜app 米老鼠直播app 梦幻直播app 繁花直播app 盘她直播app 鲍鱼视频app 草莓app 菠萝蜜 快猫视频app 猛虎视频 火爆社区app 丝瓜视频污app 蜜桃直播app 依恋直播app 冈本视频app 内裤直播 陌秀直播 A头条app 鲍鱼视频 香蕉直播 盘他直播app 暖暖直播app 7秒鱼直播 葡萄视频app health2下载app视频免费最新 草莓app 卡哇伊直播app 丝瓜草莓视频app 尤蜜视频app 蚪音 十里桃花直播 水晶直播 樱花视频app 猛虎直播 小花螺直播app 可乐视频 硬汉视频app 小宝贝直播app 91直播下载app视频免费最新 ML聚合下载app视频免费最新 大小姐直播 A头条app 雨云直播 最污直播 芭乐视频 Avnightapp Avboboapp 比心 七秒鱼直播app 富二代f2抖音 成人快手app Avnightapp 繁花直播app 快猫短视频app 铁牛 Huluwa 暖暖直播app 榴莲视频app 黄瓜视频人 花样视频 蓝颜 享爱直播 草鱼app 小草莓app 7秒鱼直播app 小v视频 花仙子直播 依恋直播 鲍鱼视频 红颜 千层浪视频app 花狐狸直播app swag台湾 免费黃色直播app 夜巴黎直播app 雨云直播 香草视频 红娘直播 富二代f2app 小优 免费黃色直播app 91香蕉app 粉色视频 swag台湾app 粉色视频app 和欢视频下载app视频免费最新 蚪音app 九尾狐直播app s8视频app 豆奶短视频app 茄子视频 逗趣直播 番茄社区 月光直播 大菠萝 主播福利 榴莲视频app 含羞草视频app 云上花直播app 香蕉 香蕉直播 红娘直播 可乐视频 盘她app AVBOBO下载app视频免费最新 swag台湾 69视频app 粉色视频 丝瓜视频污app 探花直播 富二代f2 年华直播 泡芙视频 七秒鱼 左手视频app 杏趣直播 福利直播 性福宝 fi11含羞草app 草鱼 秀儿直播 富二代f2抖音app 成版人快手app 菠萝蜜视频app 葫芦娃app 初见直播 微杏app 红颜app MM直播app 快猫视频app 红颜app 樱花直播 柠檬视频app 色秀直播app 红玫瑰直播app fi11含羞草 蓝精灵直播 微杏app 尤蜜视频 豆奶app lutubeapp 蘑菇视频app 富二代f2抖音 泡芙视频app 比心 9uu 恋人直播app 性福宝app 麻豆传媒视频 豆奶视频 富二代f2抖音 小奶狗视频app iAVBOBOapp 花心 swag台湾app 彩云直播 杏花直播app 水果视频app 抖阴 初恋视频app 蚪音 卖肉直播 尤蜜视频app 朵朵直播 大象视频app 花心直播 内裤直播app 丝瓜视频污app 九尾狐直播app 草榴直播app 享爱app 桃花下载app视频免费最新 69视频 丝瓜 小蝌蚪视频app 红杏视频app 大象视频app 9uuapp 成版人抖音app 大番号 恋人直播 桃花直播app 迷雾直播app 七秒鱼 69热下载app视频免费最新 小奶猫app 花姿 雨云直播 蚪音 美梦视频app 最污直播 大西瓜视频 乐购直播 富二代短视频 年轻人片app 探探直播 茄子直播app 薰衣草直播app 柚子直播app 花仙子直播app f2富二代app 好嗨哟直播 BB直播 小天仙直播app 污直播app 薰衣草直播app 依恋直播app 丝瓜app 泡芙app 蜜柚直播 香蕉直播app fi11含羞草 小v视频app 台湾swagapp 柠檬视频 大秀直播app 左手视频app 东京视频 年华直播 葫芦娃视频 花心直播 左手视频 花样视频 千层浪app 左手视频app 遇见直播app 水晶直播 笔芯直播app 茄子视频app 香草视频 麻豆传媒直播 柠檬视频 彩云直播 比心直播 红玫瑰直播app 柠檬视频 富二代短视频 大番号 美梦视频 金屋藏娇直播间app 豆奶app 性直播app 大菠萝 丝瓜草莓视频app 红玫瑰直播app 快猫视频 小天仙直播 小蝌蚪视频 花心社区 抖阴视频app 可乐视频 葫芦娃 卖肉直播 樱花视频app 番茄直播 夜猫视频 s8视频 梦幻直播app 樱桃视频app 7秒鱼直播 最污直播app 美梦视频app 茶馆视频下载app视频免费最新 小优 微啪app 斗艳直播app 葫芦娃视频 小优 黄瓜视频 avgoapp 微杏app 月亮直播app 尤蜜视频app 蜜柚app 麻豆传媒视频app 小奶狗 皮卡丘直播 香蕉直播 木瓜下载app视频免费最新 茄子视频 卖肉直播app 云上花 玉米视频 IAVBOBO 月亮视频 蜜橙视频 快猫app 盘她 骚虎直播 七秒鱼下载app视频免费最新 富二代app 含羞草app 小怪兽app 烟花巷直播app 大象视频 荔枝 ML聚合 享爱app 蘑菇视频 IAVBOBO 小v视频app 美岁直播 一对一直播app 暗夜直播app 妖妖直播 花仙子直播app 小怪兽直播app 比心直播app 葫芦娃视频app 草莓直播 JAV名优馆 卖肉直播app 老王视频app 小怪兽 s8视频app 冈本 猫咪视频app 金屋藏娇直播间app 盘她 成版人快手 麻豆传媒视频app 比心app 菠萝蜜视频app 久草 遇见直播app 小奶狗视频app MM直播 BB直播app 考拉直播app 泡芙短视频 丝瓜草莓视频 水仙直播app 名优馆app 蜜蜂视频app 香蕉直播app 夏娃直播 ML聚合 午夜神器 花心app 杏趣直播app 四虎app 豆奶抖音短视频 成人快手 茶馆视频app 红高粱直播app 暗夜直播app 小怪兽直播 花粥直播 橙子直播 九尾狐直播app swag视频app 花心 小喵直播app 西瓜直播app 大秀直播 云上花直播下载app视频免费最新 柠檬视频 美梦视频app 成人快手app 暖暖直播app 7秒鱼直播下载app视频免费最新 花姬 iavboboapp 夜巴黎直播 野花视频app 福利直播 香蜜直播app 冈本 小草视频app 豆奶视频 夜猫视频app 探花直播 红楼直播app 音色短视频 夏娃直播 朵朵直播app 9uu 花仙子直播下载app视频免费最新 小宝贝直播 九尾狐直播 A头条app 左手视频 6房间视频直播 97豆奶视频下载app视频免费最新 黄页荔枝 卡哇伊直播 大西瓜视频app 乐购直播app 午夜直播间app 豌豆直播app 啪嗒视频app 小蝌蚪视频app 左手视频 花心直播 成版人音色短视频app 享爱app 富二代短视频 午夜神器app health2 秀儿直播下载app视频免费最新 iAVBOBOapp 91香蕉app 美梦视频 卡哇伊直播 麻豆传媒 d2天堂 樱桃视频 一对一直播 千层浪直播 午夜直播间 快喵 灭火卫视 卡哇伊app 水果视频app 色秀直播 盘他app 杏趣直播app 柠檬视频 大番号app 蝴蝶直播app 恋夜秀场 富二代短视频app 蝶恋花 d2天堂app 金鱼直播app 成版人短视频app 性直播 尤蜜视频 红楼直播app 9uu 香草视频app 暖暖直播app 9uu 抖阴视频 iAVBOBOapp 鲍鱼视频 草榴直播app 向日葵app 牛牛视频 Kitty直播 红高粱直播 牛牛视频 橙子视频app IAVBOBOapp 快猫视频app 暗夜直播app 恋夜秀场 云上花下载app视频免费最新 樱花直播app 快猫短视频下载app视频免费最新 夏娃直播app 97豆奶视频app 葫芦娃视频app 葫芦娃视频app 性福宝app d2天堂app BB直播 s8视频 梦幻直播下载app视频免费最新 樱花雨直播 91直播 探探直播 性福宝app 富二代f2抖音 久草app 盘她 ML聚合下载app视频免费最新 云上花 小怪兽app Kitty直播下载app视频免费最新 成人直播 柠檬直播 心上人直播 恋人直播app 秀儿直播下载app视频免费最新 暗夜直播 小猪视频app 野花视频 樱花视频 野花视频 秀色直播 红楼直播 暗夜直播 柠檬视频 富二代f2短视频app 玉米视频app 小草视频 丝瓜 享爱 逗趣直播app 免费黃色直播 水蜜桃 樱花直播app 红颜 后宫 大菠萝app 嘿嘿连载app 水蜜桃app 荔枝app 考拉直播app 欢喜视频app 红楼直播app 红玫瑰直播app 柠檬视频 七秒鱼直播app 免费黃色直播 小蝌蚪app 秀色直播app 考拉直播 硬汉视频app 小天仙直播app 卡哇伊 秋葵视频app 7秒鱼直播app 么么直播app 水晶直播app 合欢视频 盘她app 柚子直播app 恋夜秀场 萝卜视频 丝瓜 花姬直播app 花姬直播app 青青草app BB直播 黄瓜视频人 橘子视频 番茄视频 小怪兽直播app 大小姐直播 米老鼠直播 69热app 花心直播app 和欢视频下载app视频免费最新 啪嗒视频app 台湾swagapp AVBOBO 依恋直播app 黄瓜视频 小草莓 小公主直播 快播破解 荔枝 9uuapp 食色 趣播 蘑菇视频app 遇见直播 玉米视频app 冈本 小奶狗 斗艳直播app f2富二代app 蝴蝶直播app 成版人茄子视频app 富二代app 七秒鱼直播app 享爱 橙子视频 享受直播 花姿直播app 梦露直播app 台湾swagapp 富二代f2抖音下载app视频免费最新 花仙子直播 红高粱直播 七秒鱼直播app 享爱app 暗夜直播app 向日葵视频 黄色直播软件 泡芙 望月app 尤蜜视频下载app视频免费最新 麻豆传媒视频 抖阴视频app 冈本视频app 逗趣直播 黄色直播软件app 仙人掌 樱花视频 主播福利 蜜橙视频app 夜巴黎直播 茄子直播app 草榴短视频 大小姐直播app 彩云直播app JAV名优馆 小怪兽app 丝瓜草莓视频 好嗨哟直播 雨燕直播 小奶狗 杏花直播下载app视频免费最新 樱桃直播 小小影视app 成版人音色短视频 草鱼app 葫芦娃视频app 快猫视频app 冈本app 鸭脖视频app 月亮直播 幸福宝 iAVBOBO 大小姐直播 美岁直播 丝瓜草莓视频 梦幻直播下载app视频免费最新 麻豆视频app 盘她直播app 成人直播 蜜桃直播 AVBOBOapp 主播大秀app 音色短视频 遇见直播 污软件app 夜夜直播app 红娘直播 樱桃app 小奶狗视频 啪嗒视频 夜狼直播app 红娘直播app 千层浪app 丝瓜草莓视频 柚子直播 杏花直播 迷雾直播 Kitty直播app 91直播app 性福宝app 妖妖直播 向日葵app 桃花app 梦幻直播 尤蜜视频下载app视频免费最新 IAVBOBOapp 泡芙视频 9uu 久草 7秒鱼直播下载app视频免费最新 91视频app 成版人快手app 压寨直播 卡哇伊直播 夜猫视频app 含羞草视频app 千层浪直播 花心视频 花样视频app Avbobo下载app视频免费最新 快猫 番茄视频app 香草成视频人 快猫视频 69视频app 成人直播 硬汉视频下载app视频免费最新 灭火卫视app 红玫瑰直播 初见直播app 左手视频app 初见直播 九尾狐直播app 富二代f2抖音 初见直播 菠萝菠萝蜜视频 皮卡丘直播 菠萝蜜视频app 成版人茄子视频 朵朵直播 Kitty直播 云上花直播app 杏趣直播 光棍影院 色秀直播app 菠萝蜜视频app Avbobo下载app视频免费最新 久草视频 茶馆视频下载app视频免费最新 左手视频下载app视频免费最新 黄色直播软件app 和欢视频下载app视频免费最新 烟花直播app 桃花app 咪哒直播app 荔枝app ML聚合下载app视频免费最新 小蝌蚪视频app 麻豆传媒映画 梦幻直播 菠萝蜜视频 黄色直播软件app d2天堂app 黄页荔枝app 好嗨哟直播 小怪兽直播 豆奶视频app 云上花app 考拉直播 初见直播app 最污直播 樱花app 花心社区app 抖阴 抖阴 猛虎直播 IAVBOBO 抖阴app 红玫瑰直播下载app视频免费最新 四虎app 橙子直播 蝶恋花直播 香草视频 成版人快手app 微杏 音色短视频app 乐购直播